In the Quran, Allah gives an extraordinary and rather puzzling threat: He will erase the faces of those who disobey him, as stated in Surah 4:47 and 7:164. But when we pause to think about it, this claim raises more questions than it answers. Has anyone—at any point in history—ever had their face erased or reaaranged by divine decree? If this was a genuine punishment, shouldn’t there be countless stories of faceless people wandering around, living as proof of Allah’s power? Yet, there isn’t a shred of evidence, no historical accounts, no eyewitnesses, no records of anyone suffering such a fate.
The whole concept feels more like an ancient fable designed to terrify the uneducated in the desert. If Allah is truly omnipotent, wouldn’t there be far more effective ways to correct disobedience? What would erasing faces achieve?
Instead of resorting to hollow threats that sound more like a Saturday morning cartoon, why wouldn’t an all-knowing deity use wisdom, compassion, or reason to guide those who stray from the path? If the goal is to teach obedience, wouldn’t it be more effective to appeal to people’s intellect or moral sense rather than wiping out their eyes, nose, mouth?
It’s hard to ignore how silly and over-the-top this threat feels. The idea of a faceless populace, stumbling around in confusion, almost sounds like a joke or bad scene from a B grade horror movie. Can anyone take it seriously? Theatrics like these seem more fitting for folklore than for a religious text claiming to offer ultimate truth and moral guidance.
The entire concept feels hollow and superficial, as if it was designed to scare people into submission. That’s what it probably was. Muhammad’s attempts to get people to follow him. If this is truly the best form of punishment Allah can come up with, it leaves one wondering whether this is really a wise omnipotent being or simply a fear-driven myth, struggling to maintain authority through empty threats.
This so-called divine punishment lacks not only evidence but also reason. It’s not the mark of justice or guidance, but rather a shallow attempt to instill fear in a way that is laughable.